October 14, 2026

Should You Give a Recorded Statement to the Insurance Company After an Accident in New York?

If you have been in a car accident, there are a lot of things you can expect to deal with: car repairs, doctor's visits, paperwork, and maybe even a call from an insurance adjuster. Most likely they will want you to answer a few questions and let you know they are going to record it, but before you say yes, here's what you should know.

Do you have to speak to the insurance company?

If you were hit by another driver, their insurance company is not calling to look out for your best interests. Their job is to make sure they don't pay out more than they should for either side in an accident. So when they want to speak to you, in most cases you are not legally required to give the at-fault driver's insurance company a recorded statement. You can decline and then speak with your attorney.

Why can a recorded statement hurt your claim?

Insurance adjusters are trained to ask questions that may sound harmless, but your answers could be used against you later. Here are some scenarios that could be misconstrued:

  • The insurance adjuster asks you, "How are you feeling?" If you say fine or okay, they could claim you weren't injured, when in fact that's a response you would give out of habit. You may also feel fine in that moment, but pain and injury from an accident can show up days later.
  • They may ask you who was at fault. Saying something like "They came out of nowhere!" could be twisted to imply you weren't paying attention and didn't see the other driver.
  • The insurance adjuster may ask you how fast you were going. You won't be able to give an accurate answer unless you were looking at your speedometer at the exact moment of the accident, and a police report or even your car's computer could contradict you.

Do I have to give a recorded statement to my own insurance company?

The short answer is yes, you may be required to. New York's no-fault system has its own rules and deadlines for reporting a crash and filing for benefits. Don't ignore the call from your insurance company, but when you speak to them, ask them to send any questions in writing, and then contact your attorney.

Talk to an accident attorney first

The best first move if you have been injured in a car accident is to speak with an attorney. We can handle the calls for you, protect your rights, and make sure nothing you say is used against you. Contact our office today for a free consultation. We'll deal with the insurance companies so you can focus on healing.

Need help?

Talk with Stern & Stern

Get straightforward guidance from a personal injury attorney serving Freeport and Long Island.

Book a consultation 516-634-0345
← Back to all articles

Been in an accident? Let's talk today.

Free consultation. No fee unless we recover for you.

Call 516-634-0345